Double Wishbone vs. MacPherson Strut Suspension
May 20, 2024
The Double Wishbone and MacPherson Strut are two types of suspension systems commonly used in vehicles, and each has its distinct characteristics and advantages.
-
Double Wishbone Suspension:
- Structure: This system uses two wishbone-shaped arms to locate and control the wheel. Each arm, one upper and one lower, connects the wheel assembly to the vehicle’s frame and allows for precise control of the wheel throughout its range of motion.
- Performance: The double wishbone design provides better camber control and allows for better handling characteristics. It is preferred in high-performance and luxury vehicles because it can be finely tuned for better dynamics.
- Space: It typically takes up more space than a MacPherson strut due to its complexity.
-
MacPherson Strut Suspension:
- Structure: This system uses a single larger strut that combines a shock absorber and a coil spring as a single unit, along with a lower control arm. The strut itself bears a significant portion of the vertical load and serves as a pivot point for the steering operation.
- Performance: While not allowing as much control over the wheel motion as a double wishbone, the MacPherson strut is generally cheaper to manufacture and simpler to install. It offers sufficient performance for most standard vehicles and is commonly found in compact and economy cars.
- Space: The MacPherson strut is more compact, making it suitable for vehicles where engine bay and wheel arch space is limited.
Application Differences:
- The double wishbone suspension is often used in sports cars and vehicles where performance, including better handling and ride quality, is a priority.
- The MacPherson strut, due to its simplicity and cost-effectiveness, is commonly used in front-wheel-drive cars and increasingly in compact SUVs.
Each system has its pros and cons, making them suitable for different types of vehicles based on the required handling characteristics, cost constraints, and space availability.